Screenwriters and Multiple Authorship: Preliminary Reflections Across Political Sociology and Film Criticism
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.6092/issn.2280-9481/11018Keywords:
Authorship, Screenplay , Politics, Power, OrganizationAbstract
According to Crozier and Friedberg, organizations are not rational structures but arenas in which every actor is engaged in a struggle of power with other actors. The article adopts their approach in order to understand one of the most important features of film production, the relationship among directors and screenwriters. Most film critics and viewers tend to discuss films as if they are products of a single author (usually the director). The article challenges this view. It adopts a “multiple authorship” perspective and uses examples from the history of cinema to show how screenwriters have left their personal sign on films. In order to build a convincing theory of “multiple authorship”, it is necessary to understand the relations of collaboration and conflict among the numerous actors involved in making a film. Therefore, the article focuses on the relationship between directors and screenwriters and outlines a typology that identifies five different ideal types of relationship between these two crucial roles. The article aims to provide a first conceptualization for a sociological study about the activity of screenwriters and about their contribution to the making of a film.
References
Alonge, Giame (2012). Scrivere per Hollywood. Venezia: Marsilio.
Angelucci, Gianfranco e Liliana Betti, a cura di (1974). Il film Amarcord. Bologna: Cappelli.
Baker, Wayne E. e Robert R. Faulkener (1991). “Role as resource in the Hollywood film industry”- American Journal of sociology, 97(2): 279-309.
Banks, Miranda J. (2010). “The picket line online: Creative labor, digital activism and the 2007–2008 Writers Guild of America strike”. Popular Communication, 8(2): 20-33.
Banks, Miranda J. (2015). The Writers: A History of American Screenwriters and Their Guild, New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Banks, Miranda J. e David Hesmondhalgh (2016). “Internationalizing Labor Activism: Building Solidarity Among Writers’ Guilds.” In Precarious Creativity: Global Media, Local Labor, a cura di Miranda Banks e David Hesmondhalgh, 267-280. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Baschiera, Stefano (2014). "I registi-sceneggiatori". Quaderni del Csci, 10: 63-67.
Becker, Howard Saul (1974). “Art as a collective action”. American sociological review, 39(6): 767-776.
Becker, Howard Saul (1982). I mondi dell’arte. Bologna: Il Mulino, 2004.
Bielby, Denise D. e William T. Bielby, (1996) “Women and men in film. Gender inequality among writers in a culture industry”. Gender & Society. 10(3): 248-270.
Bielby, Denise D. e William T. Bielby, (1999) “Organizational mediation of project-based labor markets: Talent agencies and the careers of screenwriters”, American sociological review, 64(1): 64-85.
Blair, Helen (2001). “You’re only as good as your last job. The labour process and labour market in the British film industry”. Work employment society. 15 (1): 149-169.
Bloore, Peter (2012) The Screenplay Business. Abingdon: Routledge.
Bogdanovich, Peter (1990). Il cinema secondo John Ford. Parma: Pratiche.
Bondanella, Peter E. (1994). Il cinema di Federico Fellini. Rimini: Guaraldi.
Brunetta, Gian Piero (1998). Storia del cinema italiano. 1963-1993. Roma: Editori Riuniti.
Calasso, Roberto (1991). I quarantanove gradini. Milano: Adelphi.
Caldiron, Orio e Matilde Hochkofler (1988). Scrivere il cinema. Suso Cecchi d’Amico. Roma: Gremese.
Caldwell, John T. (2013). “Authorship below-the-line.” In A Companion to media authorship, a cura di Jonathan Gray e Derek Johnson, Malden, 349-369. MA: Wiley.
Capra, Frank (1989). Il nome sopra il titolo. Roma: Lucarini.
Cattani, Gino e Simone Ferriani (2008). “A Core/Periphery Perspective on Individual Creative Performance: Social Networks and Cinematic Achievements in the Hollywood Film Industry”, Organization Science, 19(6): 824-844.
Cattani, Gino, Simone Ferriani, e Paul D. Allison, P. D. (2014). “Insiders, Outsiders, and the Struggle for Consecration in Cultural Fields: A Cor/ePeriphery Perspective”, in “American Sociological Review”, 79(2): 258-281.
Cavallaro, G. B. a cura di (1955). Senso, Bologna: Cappelli.
Cecchi d’Amico, Susi (1975). “Il destino dei complici”. In Gruppo di famiglia in un interno, a cura di Giorgio Treves, 17-18. Bologna: Cappelli.
Cederna, Camilla, a cura di (1963). Otto e mezzo. Bologna: Cappelli, 1963.
Chiarini, Luigi (1940). “Chi è l’autore del film?”, Film, 3(34): 3.
Chiesa, Guido (2014). “Dall’idea al film. Il rapporto tra sceneggiatore, regista e produttore”, Quaderni del Csci, 10: 54-57.
Chris, Cynthia e David Gerstner, a cura di (2013). Media authorship. New York: Routledge.
Christopherson, Susan (1996). “Flexibility and Adaptation in Industrial Relations: The Exceptional Case of the U.S. Media Entertainment Industries”. In Under the Stars: Essays on Labor Relations in Arts and Entertainment, a cura di Lois S. Gray e Ronald Leroy Seeber, 86 – 112. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
Christopherson, Susan e Michel Storper (1989). “The effects of flexible specialization on industrial-politics and the labor-market. The Motion Picture industry”. Industrial and labor relations review, 42 (3): 331-347.
Comand, Mariapia (2018). “Furio Scarpelli”, in Dizionario biografico degli italiani, vol. 91, <https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/furio-scarpelli_(Dizionario-Biografico)/>.
Cowan, Philip (2017). “Analyzing Stylistic Patterning in Film to Establish the Cinematographer as a Coauthor”, Projections, 11(1): 16-37.
Crozier, Michel e Erhard Friedberg (1978). Attore sociale e sistema. Milano: Etas.
Davis, Ronald L. (1993). The Glamour factory. Inside Hollywood’s Big Studio System, Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press.
Della Casa, Steve e Francesco Ranieri Martinotti (2009). “Introduzione”. In Mario Monicelli, Il mestiere del cinema, a cura di Steve Della Casa e Francesco Ranieri Martinotti, 7-27. Roma: Donzelli.
Di Carlo, Carlo a cura di (1971) La pacifista di Miklòs Jancso. Bologna: Cappelli.
DiMaggio, P. J. (1977) “Market Structure, the Creative Process, and Popular Culture: Toward an Organizational Reinterpretation of Mass Culture Theory”, Journal of Popular Culture, 11(2): 433-51.
Ellingsen, Steinar e Stayci Taylor (2019). “Writers, Producers and Creative Entrepreneurship in Web Series Development”. In Palgrave Handbook of Screen Production, a cura di Craig Batty, Marsha Berry, Kath Dooley, Bettina Frankham, Susan Kerrigan, 181-191. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Farchy, Joelle (2007) “Économies des droits d’auteur II – Le cinema”. Culture études, 5: 1-20.
Faulkner, Robert R. e Andy B. Anderson, (1987). “Short-term projects and emergent careers: evidence from Hollywood”, in American journal of sociology. 92(4): 879-909.
Flaiano, Ennio (1995). Soltanto le parole. Lettere (1933-1972). Milano: Bompiani.
Gambetti, Giacomo, a cura di (1964). Sedotta e abbandonata. Bologna: Cappelli.
Gandin, Michele, a cura di (1956). Il tetto. Bologna: Cappelli.
Gandini, Leonardo (1998). La regia cinematografica. Roma: Carocci.
Garofalo, Marcello (2020). Il cinema è mito. Vita e film di Sergio Leone. Roma: Minimum Fax.
Gaut, Berys (2010). A Philosophy of Cinematic art. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gay, Andrew Kenneth (2014). “Start me up: Lean screenwriting for American entrepreneurial cinema”, Journal of Screenwriting, 5(2): 259-75.
Gerstner, David A. e Janes Staiger (2003). Authorship and film. New York: Routledge.
Grant, Barry Keith (2007). Film Genre: From Iconography to Ideology. London: Wallflower, 2007.
Gray, Jonahan e Derek Johnson, a cura di (2013). A companion to media authorship. Malden, MA: Wiley.
Grodal, Torben Kragh.(2004). “Agency in Film, Filmmaking and Reception”. In Visual Authorship. Creativity and Intentionality in Media, a cura di Torben Kragh Grodal, Bente Larsen e IbenT. Laursen, 15- 36. Copenaghen: Museum Tusculanum Press.
Hirsch, Paul M. (1972). “Processing Fads and Fashions: An Organization-Set Analysis of Cultural Industry Systems”, American Journal of Sociology, 77 (4): 639-59.
Infantino, Lorenzo (2013). Potere. La dimensione politica dell’azione umana. Soveria Mannelli: Rubbettino.
Jarvie, Ian C. (1977). Una sociologia del cinema. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Kerrigan, S. e Batty, C. (2016) “Re-conceptualising sreenwriting for the academy: the social, cultural and creative practice of developing a screenplay”. New writing, 13(1): 130-144.
Kipen, David (2006). The Schreiber Theory: A Radical Rewrite of American Film History. New York: Melville House.
Paul, Aran e Archie Kleingartner (1996). “The Transformation of Industrial Relations in the Motion Picture and Television Industries”. In Under the Stars: Essays on Labor Relations in Arts and Entertainment, a cura di Louis S. Gray e Ronald L. Seeber. 156-80. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
Laberge, Yves (1997). “La notion d’auteur et le droit d’auteur au cinéma : aperçu historique, juridique et sociologique”, Les Cahiers de droit, 38(4): 899-917.
Lanzi, Lucrezia (2019). “Luigi Malerba. Materialità del possibile tra parola e immagine”. In Interferenze. Registi/scrittori e scrittori/registi nella cultura italiana, a cura di Denis Brotto e Attilio Motta, 89-98. Padova: Padova University Press.
Levy, Emanuel (1988). John Wayne: Prophet of the American Way of Life. Metuchen, Scarecrow Press.
Liberman, Evan e Kerry Hegarty, (2010). “Authors of the Image: Cinematographers Gabriel Figueroa and Gregg Toland”, Journal of Film and Video, 62 (1-2): 31-51.
Livingston, Paisley (1997). “Cinematic Authorship”. In Film Theory and Philosophy, a cura di Richard Allen e Murray Smith, 132-48. Oxford - New York: Oxford University Press.
Mancino, Anton Giulio (2014). “Bernardino Zapponi”, in Russo (2014, 212).
Maule, Rosanna (2014). “Politiche per lo sviluppo: industria, leggi e finanziamenti”, Quaderni del Csci, 10: 68-75.
Medioli, Enrico (1973). “Ludwig o della solitudine”. In Ludwig, a cura di Giorgio Ferrara, 31-32. Bologna: Cappelli.
McGilligan, Patrick (1982). James Cagney, The Actor as Auteur. New York: Barnes and Company.
McGrath, Declan e Felim MacDermott (2003). Sceneggiatura: i maestri del cinema. Monteveglio: Atlante.
Michaelis, Juliana (2015). Film Editor as Auteur: an Exploration of Walter Murch's Editing Style: Statistical Style Analysis and Scene Comparison. Riga: Akademiker Verlag.
Mittell, Jason (2017). Complex Tv. Roma: Minimum Fax.
Montesanti, Fausto, a cura di (1958). L’uomo di paglia. Bologna: Cappelli.
Morgan, Gareth (1986). Images. Le metafore dell’organizzazione. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Murray, Virginia S. (2014). “Collaborative authorship in film production: Walter Murch and film editing”. In The international Journal of New Media, Technology and the Arts, 8(2): 9-19.
Navar-Gill, A. (2018) “The Fan/Creator Alliance: Social Media, Audience Mandates, and the Rebalancing of Power in Studio–Showrunner Disputes”. Media Industries, 5(2): 19-34.
Ottieri, Ottero (1962). Scoperta del cinema, in L’eclisse, a cura di John Francis Lane, 31-34. Bologna: Cappelli.
Pacchioni, Federico (2014). Inspiring Fellini. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Panebianco, Angelo (1989). “Organizzazione e potere.” In L’analisi della politica, a cura di Angelo Panebianco: 255-87. Bologna: Il Mulino.
Pardo, Alexandro (2010). “The film producer as a creative force”, Widescreen, 2(2): 1-23.
Pergolari Andrea (2004). La fabbrica del riso: 32 sceneggiatori raccontano la storia del cinema italiano. Roma: Un mondo a parte.
Perniola, Ivelise (2005). “Sceneggiatura e sceneggiatori”. In Storia del cinema italiano, a Acura di Vito Zagarrio, 1977/1985, vol. XIII, 237-51. Venezia-Roma: Marsilio-Bianco & Nero.
Pescatore, Gugliemo (2006). L’ombra dell’autore. Roma: Carocci.
Piccolo, Francesco (2015). “La sceneggiatura è un amalgama indivisibile”, Cineforum, 55(1): 82-84.
Ray, Robert B. (2011). The Mystery of Movie Stardom, “New England Review”, 32, 4, 175-184.
Reggiani, Stefano (1975). “L’altro occhio della realtà”. In Professione: reporter, a cura di Carlo Di Carlo. Bologna: Cappelli, 1975: 9-25.
Russo, Paolo, a cura di (2014). “Nero su bianco. Sceneggiatura e sceneggiatori in Italia”, Quaderni del Csci, 10.
Sanguineti, Tati (2015). Il cervello di Alberto Sordi. Rodolfo Sonego e il suo cinema. Milano: Adelphi.
Schatz, Thomas (1988). The Genius of the System: Hollywood Filmmaking in the Studio Era. New York: Pantheon.
Sellors, C. Paul (2007). “Collective authorship in film.” The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism. 65 (3): 263-271.
Sesti, Mario (1997). Il cinema di Pietro Germi. Milano: Baldini & Castoldi.
Sorlin, Pierre (2015). Introduzione a una sociologia del cinema. Ets: Pisa, 2017.
Stollery, Martin (2009). “Technicians of the Unknown Cinema: British Critical Discourse and the Analysis of Collaboration in Film Production.” Film History: An International Journal, 21(4): 373–393.
Staiger, Janet (1979). “Dividing labor for production control: Thomas Ince and the rise of the studio system”. Cinema Journal, 18(2): 16-25.
Staiger, Janet (1985). “The Hollywood Mode of Production to 1930.” In The Classical Hollywood Cinema, a cura di David Bordwell, Janet Staiger e Kristin Thompson, 85–154. Columbia University Press: New York.
Staiger, Janet (1983). “Tame’ Authors and the Corporate Laboratory: Stories, Writers, and Scenarios in Hollywood”, Quarterly Review of Film Studies, 8 (4): 33-45.
Stillinger, J. (1991) Multiple authorship and the myth of solitary genius, Oxford – New York: Oxford university press.
Thompson, Robert Jay, Gary Thompson e Gary Burns, a cura di (1990). Making television: Authorship and the Production Process. New York, Westport, London: Praeger.
Thomson, David (2003). The New Biographical Dictionary of Film. London: Little Brown.
Truffaut, Franòois e Jacques Rivette (1957). “Nouvelle entretien avec Jean Renoir”, Cahiers du cinéma, 78: 11 – 54.
Vignati, Rinaldo (2015). “Francesco Piccolo. Il contributo dello sceneggiatore.”, Cineforum, 55(1): 75-84.
Vignati, Rinaldo (2016a). “Dalton Trumbo e le ferite dell’America”, Cineforum, 56(9): 64-71.
Vignati, Rinaldo (2016b). “Marcello Marchesi, autore di sceneggiature”, L’Avventura, 2(2): 231-254.
Visconti, Luchino (1979). Il mio teatro. Vol. 1 – 1936-1953, a cura di Caterina d'Amico de Carvalho e Renzo Renzi. Bologna: Cappelli.
Wasko, Janet (1981). “The Political Economy of the American Film Industry”, Media, Culture and Society, 3(2): 135-53.
Wolff, Janet L. (1981). The Social Production of art. Londra: Macmillan.
Zagarrio, Vito (2006). “Morte e rinascita del ‘mestiere’. Sceneggiatori e sceneggiature anni ’80-’90”. In Storia e storie della sceneggiatura in Italia, a cura di Mariapia Comand, 221-63. Torino: Lindau, 221-263.
Zapponi, Bernardino a cura di (1972). Roma. Bologna: Cappelli.
Zavattini, Cesare (1988). Una, cento, mille lettere. Milano: Bompiani.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Rinaldo Vignati
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
